New York 1818 State Senate, Western District

Office:
State Senate (State)
Title:
State Senator
Jurisdiction:
State
Label:
New York 1818 State Senate, Western District
Date:
1818
State:
New York
Type:
General
Iteration:
First Ballot
Office/Role:
State Senate/State Senator
Candidates:
David E. Evans, Gamaliel H. Barstow, Perry G. Childs, Samuel Payne, Jediah Prendergast, Stephen Satterlee, Augustus G. Elliott, Azel Ensworth, William H. Maynard, Albert H. Tracy, Nathaniel Allen, Caleb Baker, Samuel M. Hopkins, Jonathan Richmond, Nathaniel W. Howell, Philip King, George Huntington, Henry Leonard, Ezekiel Bacon, Luther Guiteau, George Hall, David P. Hoyt, John C. Pride, Theoron Woodruff, Joseph Kirkland, John C. Spencer, Israel Stoddard, Henry R. Storrs, George Doolittle, David Risley, John Youngs, Gilbert Howell, Daniel W. Lewis, Abraham Matteson, Jr., Ebenezer Waldron, A. Gates White, Nathan Williams, George Harper, Jr., Samuel E. Evans, Jonas Platt, Wilhelmus Mynderse, Joshua Forman, Perry Green Elsworth, David Stannard, Theodore Sill, Jared Betts, Samuel Campbell, Chester Patterson, Edward Pratt, Isaac Sutherland, Thomas R. Gold, Benjamin O. Bivens, Myron Holly, Peter Smith, William G. Tracy, Henry Case, Samuel Ferman, Perry G., Phares Gould, Clark Harris, Elisha Litchfield, Oliver Miller, David Munro, William Rogers, Matthew Carpenter, John Houghtaling, Lyman Payne, Samuel Root, Solomon Tyler, Richard W. Freeman, Dunkirk Garnsey, Ammon Hayden, Charles Hill, Jacob Houghton, John Lincklean, Samuel Tinkham, Jonah Brown, Henry Brewster, Matthew Brown, Josiah Churchill, Henry Donnelly, Oliver Gibbs, Orrin E. Gibbs, Samuel Love, Jo MacCracken, John Norse, Jonathan Palmer, Ralph Parker, Joseph Parks, Seth Pomeroy, Eli Ripley, Nathaniel Rowell, William H. Sabin, Chauncey L. Sheldon, Solomon Beebe, Lockhard Berry, John T. Burton, Not Child, Thomas Greenly, Aaron Hackley, Jr., John Hubbard, Nathaniel King, Aroswell Lamb, Dennison Palmer, Sylvanus Smalley, Jesse Townsend, Zera Averill, Thomas Beals, James D. Bemis, Cadwallader Carpenter, Isaac Q. Leake, Charles G. Olmsteed, Philo Orton, Elisha Paine, Isaac Phelps, Gile Pierce, Harry Pratt, Albert H. Publius, Daniel Swan, Joel Bristol, Jedediah Brownell, Dick Cary, Erastus Clark, Thomas E. Clark, Edward Clark, James Dana, James Dean, Henry Dwight, Perry E. Evans, Theodore S. Gold, Thomas H. Hamilton, Henry Hearsay, Jonathan N. Hinckley, Thomas H. Hubbard, Walter King, Elijah Miller, Thomas Mumford, Thomas Payne, Nathaniel Payne, Augustus Sacket, William L. Storrs, Reuben Tower, John M. Watson, Crop Carpenter, Elecom Edwards, Elias Gumaer, William Johnson, John H. Tomlinson, Thaddeus M. Wood, Gideon C. Ball, Medad Bartlett, Artimas Fay, Benjamin G. Leonard, Dudley Marvin, John Nicholas, Ebenezer F. Norton, Henry F. Penfield, Lyman Phelps, Lewis Vandclip, Daniel Field, Abraham Kap, John Selfridge, Obadiah German, Gideon Granger, Moss Kent, Hubbard W. Rathbone, Daniel Raymond, John Stevenson, Nathan Bull, John Cheney, George Guest, Elijah S. Hinman, James Husted, Elijah Jones, Jacob Miller, Alexander MacGregor Comstock, Gamaliel S. Payne, Richard Smith, Richard Townley, David Woodcock
Candidates: David E. EvansGamaliel H. BarstowPerry G. ChildsSamuel PayneJediah PrendergastStephen SatterleeAugustus G. ElliottAzel EnsworthWilliam H. MaynardAlbert H. TracyNathaniel AllenCaleb BakerSamuel M. HopkinsJonathan RichmondNathaniel W. HowellPhilip KingGeorge HuntingtonHenry LeonardEzekiel BaconLuther GuiteauGeorge HallDavid P. HoytJohn C. PrideTheoron WoodruffJoseph KirklandJohn C. SpencerIsrael StoddardHenry R. StorrsGeorge DoolittleDavid RisleyJohn YoungsGilbert HowellDaniel W. LewisAbraham Matteson, Jr.Ebenezer WaldronA. Gates WhiteNathan WilliamsGeorge Harper, Jr.Samuel E. EvansJonas PlattWilhelmus MynderseJoshua FormanPerry Green ElsworthDavid StannardTheodore SillJared BettsSamuel CampbellChester PattersonEdward PrattIsaac SutherlandThomas R. GoldBenjamin O. BivensMyron HollyPeter SmithWilliam G. TracyHenry CaseSamuel FermanPerry G.Phares GouldClark HarrisElisha LitchfieldOliver MillerDavid MunroWilliam RogersMatthew CarpenterJohn HoughtalingLyman PayneSamuel RootSolomon TylerRichard W. FreemanDunkirk GarnseyAmmon HaydenCharles HillJacob HoughtonJohn LinckleanSamuel TinkhamJonah BrownHenry BrewsterMatthew BrownJosiah ChurchillHenry DonnellyOliver GibbsOrrin E. GibbsSamuel LoveJo MacCrackenJohn NorseJonathan PalmerRalph ParkerJoseph ParksSeth PomeroyEli RipleyNathaniel RowellWilliam H. SabinChauncey L. SheldonSolomon BeebeLockhard BerryJohn T. BurtonNot ChildThomas GreenlyAaron Hackley, Jr.John HubbardNathaniel KingAroswell LambDennison PalmerSylvanus SmalleyJesse TownsendZera AverillThomas BealsJames D. BemisCadwallader CarpenterIsaac Q. LeakeCharles G. OlmsteedPhilo OrtonElisha PaineIsaac PhelpsGile PierceHarry PrattAlbert H. PubliusDaniel SwanJoel BristolJedediah BrownellDick CaryErastus ClarkThomas E. ClarkEdward ClarkJames DanaJames DeanHenry DwightPerry E. EvansTheodore S. GoldThomas H. HamiltonHenry HearsayJonathan N. HinckleyThomas H. HubbardWalter KingElijah MillerThomas MumfordThomas PayneNathaniel PayneAugustus SacketWilliam L. StorrsReuben TowerJohn M. WatsonCrop CarpenterElecom EdwardsElias GumaerWilliam JohnsonJohn H. TomlinsonThaddeus M. WoodGideon C. BallMedad BartlettArtimas FayBenjamin G. LeonardDudley MarvinJohn NicholasEbenezer F. NortonHenry F. PenfieldLyman PhelpsLewis VandclipDaniel FieldAbraham KapJohn SelfridgeObadiah GermanGideon GrangerMoss KentHubbard W. RathboneDaniel RaymondJohn StevensonNathan BullJohn CheneyGeorge GuestElijah S. HinmanJames HustedElijah JonesJacob MillerAlexander MacGregor ComstockGamaliel S. PayneRichard SmithRichard TownleyDavid Woodcock
Affiliation:FederalistFederalistFederalist
Final Result: 15750156121082851833833323232211916161613121111987777666655544444433333333322222232222222222221111111112111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
District of Western15750156121082851833833323232211916161613121111987777666655544444433333333322222232222222222221111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
Allegany County209208210---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Broome County[1]434443286142---------------------------------31-------222-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Berkshire181915--------------------------------------------1------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Chenango7677678--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Lisle1241248637--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Owego40421427----------------------------------1-------212-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Union1071073670--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Windsor697468----------------------------------3----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cattaraugus County444---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cayuga County[2]1172116829790638------4-4-12-11-----------------------------------------------1111---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Aureluis21021049161--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Brutus177175-177--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Cato7069353138-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Genoa[3]73731758----------------------------------------------------------------1---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Locke1411412140--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Mentz6767611-----------12-11-----------------------------------------------1-1----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Owasco[4]6363755--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Scipio1041037470--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Sempronius24124126213-------4-4----------------------------------------------------1-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Sterling262626---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chautauque County531540337216-----115--------------2-------------1-----------------------------1111111--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Chautauque888888------------------------------------1------------------------------1-1111--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Ellicott707070---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Gerry[5]47471334--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Hanover120119-124--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Harmony213030------9--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Pomfret1191197552-----23-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Portland3536306------2--------------2----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Ripley313131------------------------------------------------------------------1-1------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cortland County[6][7]548576374129--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Cincinnatus1031325192--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Homer6362468--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Preble[8]6464676--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Scott37371214--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Solon[9]8893128--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Truxton101101101---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Virgil8787851--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Genesee County283728842579253--29292946-2------------------4-4-----2---------21-------------------------111111111111-11111--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Madison County[10]906906417643--------2-6-4-------4---------1-----21----------1-----------------------------------------111111111111--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Brookfield9393389--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Cazenovia17017010276--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of De Ruyter53532529--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Eaton[11]1131123150--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Georgetown2122-36--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Hamilton9898389--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Lebanon3433137--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Lenox707072---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Madison54552825--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Nelson92925104--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Smithfield6666538--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Sullivan4242122---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Niagara County[12]75675670944------2-------------------------------33-------21-----------------------------------------------------1111111111111-------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Boston22-2--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Buffalo515050---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Cambria2424222--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Clarence179179178---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Concord171717---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Eden111111---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Hamburgh525252---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Hartland110111111---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Lewiston36361521--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Niagara131313---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Porter202020---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Royalton303030---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Willink211211210---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Oneida County[13][14][15][16][17]198819811439545--------7-6-3-98-777--66555-----3----1--3-----1-122-------------------1--------------------------------------------111111111111111111111111-------------------------------------
Onondaga County161116131155450----------------7---2-----------1--------3---------222222222-------------------------------------------------------------------------------111111-------------------------------
Ontario County[18]247224701484994--33366-5-1-4--------4------4-3-----11-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------1111111111---------------------
Town of Avon------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Benton------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Bloomfield------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Brighton------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Bristol------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Canandaigua------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Farmington------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Genesco------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Gorham------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Groveland------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Italy------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Jerusalem------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Lima------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Livonia------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Lyons------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Mendon------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Middlesex------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Naples------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Ontario------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Palmyra1121122686--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Penfield------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Perinton------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Phelps------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Pittsford------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Richmond------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Seneca------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Sodus------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Sparta------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Springwater------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Victor------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Williamson454545---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Seneca County[19]624626276348----------------------------------1------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------111------------------
Town of Fayette133134-133----------------------------------1---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Galen30301218-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------111------------------
Town of Junius1201203289--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Ovid109110105---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Romulus15015045108--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Wolcot828282---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Steuben County[20][21]35334929655--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------111111------------
Town of Addison121212---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Bath322932---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Canisteo8871--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Cohocton161616-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------1-------------
Town of Dansville282827---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Howard776------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------1-1------------
Town of Jersey777---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Painted Post5655254--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Prattsburgh181818---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Pulteney343434---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Reading878787---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------111---------------
Town of Troupsburg222---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town of Wayne464646---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tioga County53136639786-33-----2-2---------------------4----------------------------2-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------1111111-----
Tompkins County[22][23][24]774722478372-------10-10------------------------1----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------11111

Notes:

[1]David E. Evans received 1 vote as Daniel E. Evans.
[2]Jonathan Richmond and Caleb Baker were were candidates for U.S. House of Representatives.
[3]Samuel Payne received 1 vote as S. Payne.
[4]Samuel Payne received 25 votes as Samuel S. Paine.
[5]The Chautaque Gazette, May 5, lists no votes for Perry G. Childs.
[6]5 votes for David Evans were initially listed as being for Daniel Evans in the Original Election Returns. but they were corrected or changed prior to the Official Statewide Canvass.
[7]The Cortland Republican (Cortland, NY), May 9, lists 274 votes for Perry G. Childs.
[8]57 votes for Perry G. Childs were recorded at the Preble Town Meeting after the election, though the original election returns list 67 votes for Childs.
[9]Gamaliel H. Barstow received 5 votes as Gamaliel E. Barstow.
[10]Myron Holly received 1 vote as Myron Hawley.
[11]The Pilot lists 113 votes for Gamaliel H. Barstow.
[12]Samuel Payne received 1 vote as Samuel H. Payne.
[13]Samuel Payne received 1 vote as Samuel Paine.
[14]Gamaliel H. Barstow received 4 votes as Gamaiel Barstow, 1 vote as Gamaliel Barstow and 1 vote as Gamaliel H. Barstow, 1 vote as Gamaliel H. Barot and 1 vote as Gamaliel Briston.
[15]David E. Evans received 1 vote as David I. Evans and 6 votes as Daniel E. Evans.
[16]John Lincklean received 1 vote as John Linelean.
[17]The Utica Patriot, and Patrol (Utica, NY), May 19, and the Columbian Gazette, May 12, list 1858 votes for David E. Evans, 1419 for Perry G. Childs, and 542 for Samuel Payne in Oneida county.
[18]Samuel Payne received 1 vote as Samuel T. Payne.
[19]Samuel Payne received 1 vote as Sam'l Payne.
[20]Gamaliel H. Barstow received 4 votes as Gamaliel Barstow.
[21]David E. Evans received 1 vote as Daniel E. Evans.
[22]Samuel Payne received 170 votes as Samuel S. Payne.
[23]Gamaliel H. Barstow received 3 votes as Gamaliel G. Barstow.
[24]"Landmarks of Tompkins County" lists 806 votes for David E. Evans, 720 for Gamaliel H. Barstow, 568 for Perry G. Childs, and 371 for Samuel Payne in Tompkins county.

References:

Original Election Returns.
Original Election Books. Steuben County Court House, Bath.
Preble Town Meeting Minutes. Cortland County Historical Society.
Madison County Gazette (Morrisville, NY). April 9, 1818.
Palmyra Register (Palmyra, NY). May 5, 1818.
Auburn Gazette (Auburn, NY). May 6, 1818.
Cortland Republican (Cortland, NY). May 9, 1818.
Columbian Gazette (Utica, NY). May 12, 1818.
Auburn Gazette (Auburn, NY). May 13, 1818.
The Pilot (Cazenovia, NY). May 13, 1818.
The Albany Argus (Albany, NY). May 19, 1818.
Chautauque Gazette (Fredonia, NY). May 19, 1818.
Utica Patriot, and Patrol (Utica, NY). May 19, 1818.
The Albany Argus (Albany, NY). June 5, 1818.
The New-York Columbian (New York, NY). June 9, 1818.
Bruce, Dwight H., ed. Onondaga's Centennial: Gleanings of a Century. Vol. 1. Boston: The Boston History, 1896. 274.
Selkreg, John H., ed. Landmarks of Tompkins County New York. Syracuse, NY: D. Mason and, 1894. 29.

Page Images

handwritten notes
Phil's original notebook pages that were used to compile this election. These notes are considered a draft of the electronic version. Therefore, the numbers may not match. To verify numbers you will need to check the original sources cited. Some original source material is available at the American Antiquarian Society).

These election records were released on 11 January 2012. Versions numbers are assigned by state. Alabama, Arkansas, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, Missouri, North Carolina, Ohio, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee and Virginia are complete and are in Version 1.0. All other states are in a Beta version. For more information go to the about page.